Creation of new site for XBMC Add-Ons - Printable Version
+- XBMC Community Forum (http://forum.xbmc.org)
+-- Forum: Announcements, Info, and General Discussion (/forumdisplay.php?fid=85)
+--- Forum: XBMC General Discussion (/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Thread: Creation of new site for XBMC Add-Ons (/showthread.php?tid=118245)
- Martijn - 2012-01-16 23:16
Eldorado Wrote:But like I said to you earlier, even tho I'm working on the app that I am and sounding very much like a hypocrite.. XBMC obviously does not want to be known as *the piracy/free tv program* which is where I can see you trying to take it, I don't want to see that happen to them
If you have seen all the newbie one posters that came along here complaining that icefilms wasn't working....
I really lost the count
XBMC is so much more than that
- iR0NBiLL - 2012-01-16 23:54
I don't necessarily think highlighting XBMC by Jailbreak ATV is going to make things worse. People have been doing this for years and nobody seems to get hurt over it... what would hurt others is if all this attention to XBMC was misinterpretted to make the app appear to be the "piracy / free tv" app.
People need to know technology is not an enemy and nobody should treat hardware / software as such. The minute we start criminalizing innovations is the minute we are saying "We don't want computers anymore... take them away from us!" To criminalize computing developers should be looked at as slander and abusive behavior that does not need to be tolerated.
Clearly SOPA is at the focus of this conversation, but while that is we need to have realistic measures of sanity to help us navigate one of the most misunderstood and archaic areas of law... copyright.
To keep is short and simple, lawyers own the copyright field and computer geeks do not, so simply put... everyone needs to stick with their own professions instead of making assumptions. With this in mind, let the lawyers hash out whatever legislation they intend on pushing for and THEN... we can all worry about what is or is not fair and just... Team XBMC and anyone else beginning to speculate on what is fair, what should be done about things BEFORE a law is put out, or anything regarding SOPA is being premature about what changes will come.
Technically, the legislation is not even a formal bill yet... it's being discussed if it should be a bill and what should be included in the bill, THEN everyone will give a thumbs up or down to it. WE ARE ALL BEING VERY PREMATURE ABOUT THIS.
In short, let's not get into the debate over this stuff. Either vote for or against it, but then make sure you are not jumping to gun on new procedures before you even have something to worry about.
In short, Team XBMC and everyone else needs to chill on the assumptions and let the other industry do what they do... then you can worry about it after the fact is true, IF it becomes true.
- Abrasher - 2012-01-17 00:18
Let us keep in mind that even the WHITE HOUSE has officially come out against SOPA. Yes, that is right... the White House...
In regards to XBMC being a device for Free TV... to be honest guys... that is what it has always been for me. It was not always based on iceFilms, NaviX, FastPassTV,iceLibrary... but it was always something. Hulu, or similar, have always been the appeal - for me - with XBMC. XBMC as a system media Center is not amazing(Edit by adding: by comparison to other systems with the same abilities). XBMC as a platform for third Party inovation and streaming tools.... THAT IS THE MAGIC! This is one of the big things that makes XBMC great! THE DEVELOPERS that add to it on the regular!
I understand the frustration (somewhat) with the focus of ATV's but it is what I use... what I bought, as my medium for XBMC in my house. And it has been since the ATV1.
Now to get it working on Boxee(;
- DDDamian - 2012-01-17 01:07
Abrasher Wrote:XBMC as a system media Center is not amazing. XBMC as a platform for third Party inovation and streaming tools.... THAT IS THE MAGIC(;
And that's where ya lost my interest...
- Martijn - 2012-01-17 01:09
Abrasher Wrote:XBMC as a system media Center is not amazing. XBMC as a platform for third Party inovation and streaming tools.... THAT IS THE MAGIC
Ah well, everybody got his right on a bad opinion
- XBMCisGOD - 2012-01-17 01:53
I supported xbmchub from the beginning. Mostly because I thought the privacy stance was going to, or possible will, affect many add-ons. Ones that might be totally legal in certain countries but not in the U.S. and I think those people should have a place to view and discuss these add-ons. Then I am reading this thread and comes across this quote.............
Abrasher Wrote:XBMC as a system media Center is not amazing.
..... and my jaw dropped
I tried so many media centers before xbmc and xbmc is the only one that amazed me, and that was way before I had a clue about the add-ons.
Ha, I can see... - Abrasher - 2012-01-17 04:08
HA, sorry all... let me expound
In the discussion of XBMC as a tool for "free tv" vs. "not"
My point is simply that there are many tools out there that will let you view the movies, tv-shows, and music on your hardrive:
Windows Media Center
Boxee (XBMC based I know)
My point was that the thing I love about XBMC (in comparison) is its openness to development. The thing that set it apart was
- Third Party Skins
- Third Party Streaming Tools
All these great extras. After all I have been using XBMC far before it became so PRETTY
This was my only point. I love XBMC and if I didn't make that clear, it was simply based on the speed of my reply, I assure you
- iR0NBiLL - 2012-01-23 19:43
Eldorado Wrote:ironbill - just watch for motives and read between the lines, the rest of us voted against moving to his site as we didn't like the feel of it and was very rushed decision - why do you/we want to be put into a subforum of a site dedicated to ATV jailbreaking??
Fair points my friend!
I will think about this further before jumping in with both feet. I will also call Adam of jailbreakappletv.com later today to get his take on this.
- HenryFord - 2012-01-24 16:33
Prepare for a hefty post...
Abrasher Wrote:I tend to agree. But that is just my opinion.But that would impose other problems: XBMC is then depending on your site to function/operate which I don't think is the way to go.
I would propose (also in regard to the complete, utter mess at forum.xbmc.org - especially in the addons-section):
Well... maybe I should actually try to look at the addon-section before talking out of my a**
The proposals I stated here have been fulfilled, so... thanks @Team-XBMC
My last proposal - but this is more directed at XBMChub:
Please, create a front page and "hire" a few writers (I'm sure there are people out there who want to chime in - I for one would) - I would love to actually see a page which deals with nothing but XBMC's-Addons, providing news, reviews and instructions.
Ned Scott Wrote:You can even make sub-pages if one page isn't enough. TheCollective (guys behind add-ons like YouTube, Vimeo, Common plugin cache, etc) have done this, moving their documentation to the wiki. (should have some guidelines soon, but feel free to PM me if you have any questions about that)The thing is - is MediaWiki really the way to go here? I asked this question myself more and more in the last two weeks - i for one think that the mediaWiki is probably just not the right kind of wiki to use in this regard. I came to test out (and installing, setting up, etc., etc.) the DokuWiki in the last two weeks (coincident? I don't think so ) and to what I can gather so far it is WAY better at documenting things in a nice, neat structure than mediaWiki ist - and isn't that all the XBMC-Wiki should be about? Documentation? Maybe it would be a good idea to transfer the mediawiki to a dokuwiki-setup in order to give users a more intuitive access to the documentation they are seeking. Especially the search-function in mediawiki is so messed up, you hardly find what you were looking for in the first place. I could be of help here - helping in transfering the current wiki to a new envoirenment. Of course it would take time - but that is time I am more than willing to invest in this project.
I surely don't know the exact interna over at Team-XBMC, but maybe it would make sense to appoint someone solely to the Wiki?
Quote:XBMC as a system media Center is not amazing(Edit by adding: by comparison to other systems with the same abilities)Wait... what? With what media center do you do the comparision? I cannot see one single MC out there with the abilities, the looks and the feel of XBMC.
Edit: Just saw your reasons, and although I don't agree to all of them - they are valid points.
- Martijn - 2012-01-24 16:51
HenryFord Wrote:I would propose (also in regard to the complete, utter mess at forum.xbmc.org - especially in the addons-section):
I was already way ahead of you. I proposed this couple of posts back that was picked up immediately
It cleaned it up nicely without having to lock down the add-on section.