Do the devs dislike ION users? - Printable Version
+- XBMC Community Forum (http://forum.xbmc.org)
+-- Forum: Announcements, Info, and General Discussion (/forumdisplay.php?fid=85)
+--- Forum: XBMC General Discussion (/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Thread: Do the devs dislike ION users? (/showthread.php?tid=127521)
Do the devs dislike ION users? - RKMFlorida - 2012-04-02 12:33
I've been trying to run XBMC on ATOM/ION chipsets for years now.
I was so excited when v9 came out because I had hoped my ION chipset would work out-of-the-box. That didn't happen. After about 6 hours searching/testing, I was able to get the sound to work.
When v10 came out, I figured that would definitely be the version where ION's would work out of the box. I eventually got it working with workarounds, but it eventually stopped working properly. I switched to OpenElec and was able to get it working again.
Eden (v11) just arrived and I was really hoping that for the first time, my original ION and ION 330 (Giada Cube) would work. I did another fresh install using XBMCbuntu, yet no sound. So far I've been working on it for 4.5 hours, tested every suggested fix I can find, and yet it still crashes upon playing music or videos .. no matter what I try.
I've spent so much time working on ALSA fixes for XBMC, I'm ready to take a sledge-hammer to my ION boxes. Unfortunately I'm not a Linux guy, and although I'm trying my best, I'm at my wit's end!
If ION chipsets are always going to be such a headache, what hardware can I use that will eliminate these problems?
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - Fox - 2012-04-02 13:01
Nah they don't dislike ION users specifically, they hate all users! :-p
No but serious though, I think you must be very unlucky, sure in the beginning there was a lot of trial and error but now I find the ION work very nicely right out of the box, especially with the XBMCbuntu (formerly known as XBMCfreak) most things have worked perfectly.
But thats just for me and my ION box, there are so many different ones out there so sure some has to be troublesome.
You write that it crashes for you, maybe post some logs and someone can see what's going on.
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - davilla - 2012-04-02 13:16
I love my ION box(s), stick OpenElec on it and you are up in 10 mins. I also love my arm box(s) and atv(1,2,3)s.
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - Jezz_X - 2012-04-02 15:02
indeed my ion box runs fine on Openelec but only because I don't want to do anything but xbmc on that box so no need for a full OS
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - bossanova808 - 2012-04-02 15:26
@davilla - any chance you want to lend your mighty brain to the ION on Shuttle XS35 frame dropping issues - see:
(particularly the last couple pages...)
...FernetMenta has basically re-jigged ION video playback to make it a lot more efficient but there's an outstanding issue to do with powermizer on this particular (lovely, silent!) system..you're pretty amazing on the hardware/embedded/trick sh*t side of things so maybe you can help
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - RKMFlorida - 2012-04-02 16:12
Yes, I was running OpenElec all of v10. I switched back to XBMCbuntu because it now loads quicker and I had some issues with the dailies of OpenElec (as one should probably expect with a daily -- but it was the only way to get Eden, since OpenElec is trailing with Eden).
BTW - I do not think XBMCbuntu is the former XBMC Freak, but rather, it is the new carnation of XBMC Live. XBMC Freak was a unofficial, third-party distro, if I'm not mistaken.
After roughly 7 hours of trying dozens of different suggestions, I believe I have got a solution to get v11 running on ION. I'm posting the step-by-step below for anyone else that stumbles upon this thread:
Programs > Get More > XBMC Audio Mixer > Uninstall
Control + Alt + F1 (get command console) >
apt-get remove pulseaudio
Control + Alt + F7 (return to XBMC) -- or reboot from the command line.
System > Settings > System > Audio Output >
Audio Output: HDMI
Speaker Config: Any option (2,0, 5.1, etc)
Boost volume level on downmix: On (or) Off
AC3 capable receiver: (depends on your hardware)
DTS capable receiver: (depends on your hardware)
Audio output device: HDA NVidia - hdmi - 0 (ALSA)
Passthrough output device: HDA NVidia - hdmi - 0 (ALSA)
The "HDA NVidia - hdmi - 0 (ALSA)" will not be available until after you disable/remove the audio mixer and delete the ALSA config (.asoundrc), if you're running a similar setup to me (GIADA Cube w/ION 330).
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - darkscout - 2012-04-02 16:47
If you want a 'full OS' then you get to deal with the problems of getting sound working on a 'full OS'. This isn't an XBMC problem, this is an Ubuntu one.
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - digitalb0y - 2012-04-02 17:52
Indeed. Check out some Ubuntu forums (or even other distros) and you'll find XBMC users are not the only ones who have to tweak their ALSA settings.
RE: Do the devs dislike ION users? - voochi - 2012-04-02 22:29
Openelec works great on my Acer Revo (Atom330/Ion). Im using a nightly Eden build currently but im sure the OpenElec guys will release the stable Eden version soon.