Posts: 178
Joined: Nov 2008
Reputation:
-10
mrt2
Senior Member
Posts: 178
I'm glad I saw this thread before I purchased my new MacMini... I was suppose to sell my late 2009 (core2Duo) Mac Mini with the Nvidia gfx on Wednesday and buy the new 2011 Mac Mini but I definitely don't want to do it until it's confirmed that the performance will be ok in Lion.
OS: Leopard 10.5.6
Processor: 2x Quad Core Intel 2.8Ghz Xeon
Internal Storage: 2.4TB [4x 600GB Western Digital]
External Storage: Drobo 4.5TB
Memory: 14GB PC-6400 800mhz FB-ECC Ram
Apple Wireless Bluetooth Keyboard
Apple Remote
Posts: 50
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation:
0
I was thinking about picking up a new one, but if its currently problematic I'll wait.
Posts: 31,445
Joined: Jan 2011
This thread is really making me wonder. From the raw specs, the CPU alone (no GPU decoding), the entry level i5 mac mini should do 1080 without frame dropping (there are always exceptions, but generally speaking)
Maybe I'll go over to an Apple Store some time this week and try using XBMC on the mac minis in there. If I do I'll bring a usb drive with some test clips.
I would not be surprised if these issues were fixed with a minor update from Apple. I've heard that 10.7.1 is already in the pipeline, because devs already have the 10.7.2 beta. There's always little bumps when a new product comes out, and the new Mac Mini is both new hardware with a new OS.
Posts: 283
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
2
so far i haven't had any issues, other than getting my harmony to work right. i have the 799 model with ATI graphics. i haven't tried any bitstreaming yet, as i had a flood this weekend which killed my HTPC and the reason i went and grabbed the new mac mini. 2 of my 2 TB drives were killed which had stuff with HD Audio on them
--
Posts: 87
Joined: Jan 2011
Reputation:
0
With just the CPU alone so far it's playing back everything including some pretty 1080p files just fine as soon as you turn on hardware decoding problems start to show everywhere.
Posts: 283
Joined: Sep 2008
Reputation:
2
i am noticing that sometimes the audio output stops, and then picture playback is choppy. when this happens i have to exit XBMC, ofcourse i am using a nightly, and only tried one of them so i will test another
--
Posts: 2
Joined: Jul 2011
Reputation:
0
I was hoping to use the new mini as an HTPC.
I've had issues playing back mkv rips with my macbook pro - but everyone says even the base mini should playback mkv rips with no issue.
I was debating between:
i7 Core Duo
AMD - dedicated GPU
or
Server version
i7 Quad Core
Integrated Graphics
Which do you think is better?
Thanks
Posts: 31,445
Joined: Jan 2011
Open6l Wrote:I don't necessarily think it's a lion issue specifically as I have also tested the macmini 2010 with lion installed and it still doesn't experience the issues that the 2011 does (unless it's a compatibilty issue with lion and the 2011 intel hardware). I am going to setup bootcamp on the 2011 and see if the issue occurs under windows on the 2011 intel model.
It can still be Lion because there will always be Lion files specific to that mac mini, and it's really hard to catch bugs when it's a secret product until the same day Lion launches. Lion bugs that might be specific to the 2010 mac mini were likely caught by developers who had access to the Lion betas for a few months before hand.
Posts: 31,445
Joined: Jan 2011
lcrooks Wrote:I was hoping to use the new mini as an HTPC.
I've had issues playing back mkv rips with my macbook pro - but everyone says even the base mini should playback mkv rips with no issue.
I was debating between:
i7 Core Duo
AMD - dedicated GPU
or
Server version
i7 Quad Core
Integrated Graphics
Which do you think is better?
Thanks
For the time being it sounds like the one with the AMD GPU is a better deal. Both those have processors that are way more than enough, so at that point having a good GPU for hardware video decoding becomes the more important issue. Plus there will likely be after market kits for installing a second hard drive on the minis that only come with one hard drive.
Posts: 3
Joined: Jul 2011
Reputation:
0
So to sum it up:
Although hardware accceleration is implemented on the Mac Mini 2011 models with either the Intel or AMD gfx, it is slower than the 2010 models with Nvidia, causing unacceptable glitches and artefacts when watching HD movies.
Because of this I've decided to pick up a second hand Mac Mini 2010 /w 4GB and a 60GB SSD for much less than the entry-level Mac Mini.
Posts: 31,445
Joined: Jan 2011
user888 Wrote:So to sum it up:
Although hardware accceleration is implemented on the Mac Mini 2011 models with either the Intel or AMD gfx, it is slower than the 2010 models with Nvidia, causing unacceptable glitches and artefacts when watching HD movies.
Because of this I've decided to pick up a second hand Mac Mini 2010 /w 4GB and a 60GB SSD for much less than the entry-level Mac Mini.
I would call this speculation still. Hardware acceleration doesn't have a speed. I think we will find out if this really is a hardware issue or not, in the coming weeks. You guys could be right, but I wouldn't jump to conclusions just yet.
Regardless, I think your choice is still the best. It is far more cost effective. Mac minis from even a few years ago make great HTPCs, so there's no reason to get the latest just for that. Plus you get a DVD drive in the older models.