Posts: 793
Joined: Oct 2010
Reputation:
17
I prefer the official Android remote. Pick up an IR blaster to operate everything else and you're good to go
Posts: 71
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation:
0
The other advantage to building your own NAS is the ability to repurpose or dual purpose it later on.
There are other choices besides unRaid. For less then the cost of the synology, you could build a WHS 2011 box and run FlexRaid, Sab, Sickbeard, and SQL for all your htpc needs.
Posts: 60
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation:
0
I'm going through the same decision myself - Synology DS212j or unRAID build or combining HTPC/NAS with Win8 and it's Storage Spaces.
unRAID doesn't seem overly time consuming a project, especially since you are already building an HTPC then you've got the info and community resources right here.
But I'm concerned about the speed across the LAN. Doesn't it deliver data at slightly slower speeds than the drive it is coming from? Isn't this a future proof issue as the both the data size and number of devices in the home using the data increase?
If I were to go Synology I would probably do DS212j (2x2TB) and create some sort of backup plan between it, my workstation, external USB 3 drive, and cloud.
WRT to Win8 and Storage Spaces, if the case is cool enough, does this not provide the best of both worlds?
Van G
-eskro's A8-3870 | Win 8 | Frodo 12.2 | RC-6 | Harmony 900-
Posts: 793
Joined: Oct 2010
Reputation:
17
FlexRAID, that's what I was trying to think of earlier, not FreeRAID lol
Price-wise it's a trivial difference, but WHS is going to need stronger hardware than any of the *nix based software raid solutions
Access speed is a non-issue. With that being said, if you plan to stream 1080p, you'll want gigabit in hand. With a soft-raid solution, it's about as future proof as it gets. When a bigger/faster drive comes out, pop it in the array. Once your bays are full and you don't want to upgrade the case/mobo, just retire the smallest/slowest drive. You can grow it a little at time instead of having to upgrade whole-hog with a pre-fab nas
Posts: 53
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation:
0
Received my DS712+ and copying files now. It is super duper awesome. And if needed, easily can to switched over to another synology server; so i think it well worth it.
Oh and I was using Plex media center before and Plex has server software and client side and how about in XBMC, does it also need server software or XBMC will run totally on client.
(haven't got all the parts for the htpc so haven't started with any of the XBMC stuff, yet)
Posts: 793
Joined: Oct 2010
Reputation:
17
If you're just converting to xbmc, get ready to have you face smashed in with awesome lol.
XBMC is self contained, it can access media just about anywhere you can cram it, no server software needed
Posts: 53
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation:
0
Yep, just converting....sounds good. thanks
Posts: 1,741
Joined: Jul 2006
Reputation:
4
Regarding streaming from unRAID... for some reason my motherboard on my movie server only synchs at 100meg instead of a gig. i can run 2 different BD movies at once with no issues :-) Video is compressed and while the file sizes are fairly big it's not a big deal to stream it even on 100meg Cat5. 10meg, then it's more of an issue!
Drive loss - lose a drive in unRAId no biggie, likewise most decent RAID systems. Lose TWO drives in unRAID and you lose data but it's on standard ReiserFS drives and you do not lose the entire set. You also do not have your drives spinning full time. On regular RAID? Lose 2x drives and you lose the whole set unless you setup more redundancy. More redundancy means more drives devoted to recovery and not data storage, yuck! Recovery of RAID drives isn't simple and many data recovery services advertise their expertise at this with rates commensurate I'm sure. RAID with parity striped all over the place means all drives spin full time, again yuck!
Drive swapping on unRAID is awesome. No need to buy sets of drives, drive extenders, or anything goofy. i wait until I'm nearly out of space and THEN buy a new drive. I then swap it in place of a smaller drive or add it into a slot. Really for video streaming this works VERY well. Note that I run Sick and SAB on a desktop, I just don't want to funk with my unRAID boxes, they run great as-is. <shrug>