2012-06-17, 14:29
So finally I switched from boxee and loaded all my movies (~700 of movies and ~30 TV Shows) to XBMC library (I'm using May snapshot of Frodo). I stated using it quite intensively for few past weeks and I found few annoying (to me at least) inconsistence in user interface, or how the system can be set up or used by someone demanding a bit more than stock system. Do not take me wrong, it is by far THE BEST media center software I've seen so far, but has its own annoyances that once eliminated could make it just awesome!
So, to the details:
- I do not like Videos, Movies, TV Shows concept... While split to Movies and TV Shows makes perfect sense, from none of them you can get to files directly (if for any reason you do not want to include some of them in the library, like removable media or temporary folders). Then you need to use Videos, but this section does not give direct access to TV Shows or Movies, you need to dig there via library... what is the reason for such split? If Videos should be used primarily for Library setup, then put it under System! If for accessing files directly, then do not call it Videos, but Files and remove redundant access to Library content...
- As stated above above, I want separate Files section in main menu. I do have folders (or entire drives) from which I want to play my movies before I copy files to library controlled folders. I want to check quality or if I want to watch/save movie at all. Also sometimes friends bring their movies on removable media (so by definition not to be included in the library) and in existing setup getting to them is unnecessary complicated without direct Files menu.
- Searching is not very efficient as usually returns to many answers. Smart Playlists are way better to get quickly to movies I want to get to, but are not easily accessible :-( It is complicated to get them created from UI (e.g to find where you can create them). I even found searching the forum that lots of people do not know where to find and how to use them once created. Getting quicker access to once created Smart Playlist is possible by adding it to Favorites, but... again Favorites should be part of main menu rather than require to go way down to very bottom of the screen to invoke menu... Finally these are Favorites for some reason - so I want to access them quickly! Alternative is that once Smart Playlist is created it is automatically added as submenu of appropriate section (e.g. it appears along with Recently Added, Sets, Title Genres and so on under appropriate section; Movies, TV Shows, etc).
I'm not sure, maybe some of these concepts were already discussed in the forum... there are so many threads that is is not possible to find all posts that could touch this. So I tried to summarize flaws that I see. I hope that might inspire some of you folks to make XBMC even better!
So, to the details:
- I do not like Videos, Movies, TV Shows concept... While split to Movies and TV Shows makes perfect sense, from none of them you can get to files directly (if for any reason you do not want to include some of them in the library, like removable media or temporary folders). Then you need to use Videos, but this section does not give direct access to TV Shows or Movies, you need to dig there via library... what is the reason for such split? If Videos should be used primarily for Library setup, then put it under System! If for accessing files directly, then do not call it Videos, but Files and remove redundant access to Library content...
- As stated above above, I want separate Files section in main menu. I do have folders (or entire drives) from which I want to play my movies before I copy files to library controlled folders. I want to check quality or if I want to watch/save movie at all. Also sometimes friends bring their movies on removable media (so by definition not to be included in the library) and in existing setup getting to them is unnecessary complicated without direct Files menu.
- Searching is not very efficient as usually returns to many answers. Smart Playlists are way better to get quickly to movies I want to get to, but are not easily accessible :-( It is complicated to get them created from UI (e.g to find where you can create them). I even found searching the forum that lots of people do not know where to find and how to use them once created. Getting quicker access to once created Smart Playlist is possible by adding it to Favorites, but... again Favorites should be part of main menu rather than require to go way down to very bottom of the screen to invoke menu... Finally these are Favorites for some reason - so I want to access them quickly! Alternative is that once Smart Playlist is created it is automatically added as submenu of appropriate section (e.g. it appears along with Recently Added, Sets, Title Genres and so on under appropriate section; Movies, TV Shows, etc).
I'm not sure, maybe some of these concepts were already discussed in the forum... there are so many threads that is is not possible to find all posts that could touch this. So I tried to summarize flaws that I see. I hope that might inspire some of you folks to make XBMC even better!