What CPU should I get?
#1
My E5200 in conjuction with a cheap 8500 does ok... I can watch just about any video I've tried without stuttering, but the E5200 is moving to a new home in an Unraid server, and I want something a bit faster in here...

Something to make the menus snappier, make it feel a bit more, you know, nice...

Haven't decided whether to stay with windows or switch to linux...

Maybe an E6600?
Kodi: Kodi 17.4, with Transparency!
50 TB Unraid Server: Docker Apps: SABnzbd, Sickrage, mariaDB
HTPC: Win10 (cause Steam), i7, GTX 1080
Watching on: Panasonic TC65-PS64 with lowend Sony 5.1 HTIB
Other devices: rMBP 15", MBA 13", nvidia shield
Reply
#2
You want snappier menus? Get a SSD. My Atom HTPC with a SSD has slicker menus than my Quad with a regular HD.

Heck, with a SSD a E5200 would feel like a speed demon.
Reply
#3
+1

ssd and xbmc owns Smile everthing faster.. menues, fanart,...
CrystalHD Installer XBMC Community Forum Thread -
Apple TV CrystalHD Installer Announcement - Broadcom CrystalHD Installer
http://www.sartori.at/ - my weblog

Sync your MAC and Google Account (+ Google Apps) - Click here for 5$ Discout

Living Room: HFX Micro black - Zotac IONITX G - Intel X25V - Hama remote
Bedroom: Linux AppleTV - CrystalHD
Reply
#4
The E6600 is a step backwards from the E5200 by the way. The E6xxx series are three revisions and three generations old now. The E5200 is of the latest 775 socket fabrication type. Not the most powerful true but more than is needed for XBMC.

There where three revisions of the first true dual core of which the E6600 was part of before moving to a different die fabrication process.

The revisions were
E6xxx
E6x30
E6x50

That was followed by the E8xxx series of processors which included the E5x00, E7x00 and the Q9xxx processor within the rubric of the improved fabrication process.

The next major evolutionary step was the introduction of the 1366 socket and the 1166. Or if you prefer the i7, i5 and i3 Processors all requireing a new motherboard (socet type) and DDR3 ram.

If you need to have a Intel 775 socket CPU as an upgrade then a second hand E8400 will be more than enough. Bare in mind that with the new XBMC releases the graphic card does 99% of the work (if compatible.)

I do agree that a SSD will certainly provide the zap you are looking for.
Reply
#5
Yeah, I want to get a SSD for the XBMC... I put a 80GB Intel in my main machine, and it flies!!

Waiting for a good deal for the HTPC drive, it's less critical than the machine I use for work... Maybe I should jump now...

Would

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.as...6820211419

be a good one?

I'm thinking it's most likely going to be Linux I switch too, so I don't think there's any trim support... 30GB is more than enough space though...
Kodi: Kodi 17.4, with Transparency!
50 TB Unraid Server: Docker Apps: SABnzbd, Sickrage, mariaDB
HTPC: Win10 (cause Steam), i7, GTX 1080
Watching on: Panasonic TC65-PS64 with lowend Sony 5.1 HTIB
Other devices: rMBP 15", MBA 13", nvidia shield
Reply
#6
R_N_B Wrote:The E6600 is a step backwards from the E5200 by the way. The E6xxx series are three revisions and three generations old now. The E5200 is of the latest 775 socket fabrication type.

I think he/she is talking about the Pentium E6600 which is latest generation C2D, NOT the ancient C2D 6600!
Reply
#7
ion_man Wrote:I think he/she is talking about the Pentium E6600 which is latest generation C2D, NOT the ancient C2D 6600!

Ah thanks mate - I wondered about that. Did seem a bit strange to me.
Reply
#8
I have one of the new E6600s and I wish I didn't. It was overkill for my bedroom htpc so it sits on the shelf. Basically with GPU decoding if you need more than a single core, you are doing it wrong (except of course for Silverlight or Flash).

The SSD I put in mine was a OCZ Vertex 32gb. Honestly any SSD that supports trim would work great. I am an OCZ Vertex nut because they are the best for OSX (and in the future the SSD might end up in my hackintosh netbook.

Anandtech hot deal forum had A posting for mine for $60 AR the other day. Just hunt deals and buy when the timing is right.
Reply
#9
Note that a dual core processor has one significant advantage: Background processing (which XBMC uses a great deal now) has a separate core to use. I'd definitely get a dual core over a single core (even if it's a slower clock) all else being equal for XBMC usage.

If it comes down to a choice between SSD and single core versus HD and dual core, I'd definitely opt for the SSD though - load time is a significant day to day time waster, whereas the background processing stuff doesn't happen all the time - particularly once everything is completely configured and scanned etc.

Cheers,
Jonathan
Always read the XBMC online-manual, FAQ and search the forum before posting.
Do not e-mail XBMC-Team members directly asking for support. Read/follow the forum rules.
For troubleshooting and bug reporting please make sure you read this first.


Image
Reply
#10
Okay, thanks for the input guys...

I ordered a E6500 while waiting for input, just because it was cheap... realized that I really don't need much power anyways; either CPU is enough for AirVideo, and I decided to go Linux, so there's not many games to suck CPU power anyways...

Think I'm going to get a 32GB SSD though Big Grin

With the speed difference I noticed on my main PC going from a Velociraptor to a SSD, I bet going from a 5400RPM "green" drive to a SSD is going to blow me away...

No TRIM with linux though... maybe I should partition the HD into two halves... then every couple of months I could zero out the empty half, and clone the OS over to there?
Kodi: Kodi 17.4, with Transparency!
50 TB Unraid Server: Docker Apps: SABnzbd, Sickrage, mariaDB
HTPC: Win10 (cause Steam), i7, GTX 1080
Watching on: Panasonic TC65-PS64 with lowend Sony 5.1 HTIB
Other devices: rMBP 15", MBA 13", nvidia shield
Reply

Logout Mark Read Team Forum Stats Members Help
What CPU should I get?0