[creol]

I am trying to choose the best hardware to run XBMC. I have done a little research and have decided that there are basically two devices that I am considering. Apply TV Gen 1 and Zotac MAG HD-ND01. I really want to know other peoples opinions on both. If you have a preference... Why?

Network connectivity is not an issue. I have many options.
If I go with the Zotac I will probably go ahead and buy a Harmony 300 Remote, but any suggestions is also appreciated.

I am looking for a small device, good price(but not cheep), high quality with little to no maintenance. I can handle technical setup initially, I just don't want it to turn into one of those things where when I am out of town the wife and kids call constantly asking how to watch a show.

I am already running XBMC on a PC in one room with HDMI connection to a 32" 1080i flat tv. Using Droid Remote, Media is accessed via HP MediaSmart Home Server. It rocks I love it!

I apologize in advance if there is a thread that already discusses this. If so please respond with the URL.

[PatrickVogeli]

The Zotac ION:

- The ION decoding capabilities are much better than the Crystal HD card ones, more robust. I have a ION device and I haven't yet found a movie it won't play...
- New Vs 2nd Hand. Right now, I don't think you can get a new 1st gen apple tv, and I prefer to avoid used items. That's of course very personal.
- General: it seems the apple tv has a limited amout of memory, which is an issue with some skins. The processor isn't also much more powerful than the Dual Core Atoms, so the Zotac wins.
- Setup: the Zotac will be easier to deal with, it's a much more "open" product the any apple device.

Last one: there are some similar items to the Zotac one from the same vendor or others. Asrock, Acer, Asus, Jetway and Zotac come in mind.

[poofyhairguy]

The AppleTV only wins on cost and the ability to hook up to a older TV with component in (aka no HDMI ports). If none of those things apply, any ION system is a better experience.

[BORIStheBLADE]

I would say the Zotac is the better option for your two choices.

I had the 1st gen ATV and it doesn't compare to my new Ion 2.

[Nayuna]

You should chose Zotac, and if it is available in your Country you should chose the Zotac Zbox HD-ND22 , since this model has an dual core celeron which is much better performance than a dual atom.

http://www.silentpcreview.com/article1069-page1.html