Posts: 49
Joined: Jul 2012
Reputation:
0
That definitely works, Malibu, but I would still need some form of HDD. Either SSD or HDD. Thanks for linking that.
I'm wondering, if cutting the cost might be more feasible by going up in form factor to Micro ATX to reduce the mobo cost and using Linux or Ubuntu on some smaller and more inexpensive storage device. Would that hurt performance?
Main HTPC: i5-2500k Sandybridge 3.3Ghz - ASRock Z68 - Radeon HD6950 2GB - 8GB G.Skill Ripjaws - 64GB Crucial M4 SSD - 500GB HDD storage
Master Bedroom: G530 - ASRock H67M - 4GB Kingston HyperX - 160GB Seagate 2.5"
Living Room: Xbox 360 Media Center Extender
Posts: 49
Joined: Jul 2012
Reputation:
0
So here's the conclusion I've arrived at.
I'm either going with two ATV1s running Crystalbuntu in the next month or so and riding them for about a year before potentially considering an upgrade.
OR
I'm waiting until later in the year to potentially go with a build closer to what I listed previously in the thread.
Waiting would certainly be no fun, but is doable. The questions I have are: How long would the ATV1 setup work for me and how important is future-proofing in the HTPC game?
My main HTPC is plenty future proof and it runs on the 50" 1080p Panasonic with the surround sound, etc. The machines I am looking to build for my other two TVs will (for the time being) be running purely through the TVs and at 720p. No surround sound, no higher resolution than 720p. So is it worth it to build a setup like the G630T? Or will the ATV1 meet my needs for a year or so until upgrading becomes more worthwhile?
Main HTPC: i5-2500k Sandybridge 3.3Ghz - ASRock Z68 - Radeon HD6950 2GB - 8GB G.Skill Ripjaws - 64GB Crucial M4 SSD - 500GB HDD storage
Master Bedroom: G530 - ASRock H67M - 4GB Kingston HyperX - 160GB Seagate 2.5"
Living Room: Xbox 360 Media Center Extender
Posts: 46
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation:
0
I'm looking to do (mostly) the same thing and ditch cable for xbmc. My plan is to more ease into it though. I've got XBMC up and running on some laptops and ATV2 for now which is working but I want to switch to some proper HTPCs so I've been agonizing over the builds too.
If you're going to do a scratch build why not do it in stages? If you have an old HDD you could use that instead of an SSD. Be a little slower but save $60 there, upgrade later. Same on the fans, with the AMD builds they say the stock cooler fans are noisy but you could live with it for a while and save $25, swap the new cooler in later. Same for the picoPSU. Ram could be a single 2gb stick vs 2x2 or maybe 2x1gb but then you waste them later on. Or if you can get OpenElec running you shouldn't even need an SSD/HDD right? Just a $13 stick that you might already have.
As far as that goes though too almost any old PC will run XBMC depending on your content. I've got a laptop (winXP) with a 1.86GHz pentium single core w/ 2gb ram and it does alright up to 720p. I rip everything to 720p or less because of the ATV2. You could always buy an old PC on craigslist for now.
Might not be pretty or real quick with an old PC or half-way build but considering you're savings $100/mo that should add up quick. The other thing for myself and my wife is I'm going to go over our cable package and see what I can cut out to get the cost down in the meantime. I find I watch very little cable tv now so I can get rid of 'my' channels easy enough while I pick away at her resistance.
Posts: 89
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation:
2
I still have Directv but I havent turned it on since football season ended. If I could find a way to watch all of my games online, I would cancel it and not look back.
I would actually pay for some service to watch it online.